It has been a while since I’ve been on an email list (modern mailing lists excluded), in fact, I only recall being on one email list when I very first began using the Internet. It was a coarse angling list based in the UK. At first, the novelty of all this information flowing into my inbox was fantastic. I could read stories and learn fishing techniques which I otherwise would not have had access to but after a while, the annoying volume of emails sitting in my inbox outweighed the benefits of their content. As you can imagine, I soon unsubscribed. Information is only of value if you have the time to consume and apply it.
As magazine, THE WEEK says, “read less, know more”.
The advantage of email lists is that each message is delivered to subscribers email addresses. Since email is commonly used as a primary communication tool on the web, it is likely that the messages will be viewed, or at least seen, relatively quickly.
In today’s web, I think discussion forums are a more appropriate tool for asynchronous communication. A forum allows users to come and and go as they please, whether they participate in the conversations or not. This has the advantage of specificity, where users can be selective about which threads to view, ensuring what they read is specific to their interests. Participants can upload media files (within the limits set by the forum administrator), in the same fashion as attachments would be used via a mailing list. The disadvantage I can see with forums is the potential to miss elements of the conversation due to being absent for a period of time, however even that can be partially overcome by simply returning to the thread at a later time.
Email lists may still have a place in an internal organisation situation, where perhaps other technologies aren’t available, and there is a need for all list members to continually be up to date with certain information. Open source software development communities might be able to benefit more from an email list than a forum, if working on the same project, where input is required from a number of programmers.
In most situations, I no longer see a need for email lists, aside of course from marketing and newsletter purposes. If the prime objective is to provide a tool for discussion and discourse, then a discussion forum seems to be the most appropriate tool for doing so.






